What kind of brands can you consider buying from without disrupting your hormones
After a thorough understanding of what counts as clean beauty and reading through the table below: here are some insights:
Each brand’s products in key categories are classified as Clean (no known EDCs or harmful preservatives), Lower-Risk (free of major EDCs but may contain mild/questionable ingredients like phenoxyethanol or dimethicone), or High-Risk (contains one or more widely recognized endocrine disruptors). We also note each brand’s market presence. This analysis is based on current ingredient disclosures and “free-from” claims from official sources and safety databases.
Table 1: Makeup Categories (EDC Safety Classification by Brand)
Brand | Market | Lipstick | Lip Gloss | Blush | Highlighter | Eyeliner | Eye Shadow | Foundation/Concealer | Eyebrow Pencil | Contour |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MAC | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Clinique | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Bobbi Brown | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Estée Lauder | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Dior | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
YSL | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
NARS | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Gucci | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Glossier | Int’l Only | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean | Clean |
Brand | Market | Lipstick | Lip Gloss | Blush | Highlighter | Eyeliner | Eye Shadow | Foundation/Concealer | Eyebrow Pencil | Contour |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nykaa | India Only | High-Risk (uses parabens, BHT, synthetic fragrance) | High-Risk (parabens, fragrance likely) | High-Risk (parabens or BHT present) | High-Risk (parabens, etc.) | High-Risk (some with parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (some contain parabens/oxybenzone) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) |
FAE Beauty | India Only | Lower-Risk (no parabens/phthalates; uses safe silicones) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs; likely no parabens) | Lower-Risk (no known EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no known EDCs) | N/A (no dedicated eyeliner product) | N/A | High-Risk (Lip Balm with octinoxate & oxybenzone) | N/A | N/A |
Sugar Cosmetics | India Only | High-Risk (parabens, BHT in some lip colors) | High-Risk (contains parabens/BHT) | High-Risk (contains parabens) | High-Risk (parabens likely) | High-Risk (parabens present) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (octinoxate or parabens in base) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) |
Plum | India Only | Lower-Risk (no parabens/phthalates; may have fragrance) | Lower-Risk (similar to lipstick) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | High-Risk (sunscreens use oxybenzone, octinoxate) | N/A (no brow product) | N/A (no contour product) |
WOW Skin Science | India Only | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (similar to lipstick) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | High-Risk (SPF products have oxybenzone, octinoxate) | N/A | N/A |
Pilgrim | India Only | Lower-Risk (no parabens; contains phenoxyethanol) | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk (no known EDCs; mostly “clean”) | N/A | N/A |
Kay Beauty | India Only | Lower-Risk (no parabens; uses safe synthetics) | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk (no known EDCs; PEGs present but no parabens) | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Colorbar | India Only | High-Risk (multiple parabens, BHT) | High-Risk (parabens/BHT) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (oxybenzone, octinoxate in some) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) |
MyGlamm | India Only | High-Risk (fragrance, BHT present) | High-Risk (fragrance/BHT) | High-Risk (fragrance or others) | High-Risk (fragrance or others) | High-Risk (fragrance or others) | High-Risk (fragrance or others) | High-Risk (Oxybenzone/Octinoxate in some bases) | High-Risk (fragrance) | High-Risk (fragrance) |
Glitz Beauty | India Only | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available | Data not available |
Hince (Korea) | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; uses safe synthetics) | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk | High-Risk (foundation cushion contains octinoxate) | Lower-Risk | Lower-Risk |
Rare Beauty | Int’l Only | High-Risk (BHT used in lipstick) | Clean (tinted lip oil free of parabens/phthalates/oxybenzone) | Clean (no parabens or fragrance; safe ingredients) | Clean (no known EDCs) | Clean (no known EDCs) | Clean (no known EDCs) | Lower-Risk (foundation free of parabens/phthalates; no fragrance, but may contain safe preservatives) | Clean (no known EDCs) | Clean (no known EDCs) |
Table 2: Skincare/Misc. Categories (EDC Safety Classification by Brand)
Brand | Makeup Remover | Makeup Fixer (Setting Spray) | Lip Balm | Moisturizer | Sunscreen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nykaa | High-Risk (preservatives like parabens) | High-Risk (contains parabens; some with formaldehyde releaser) | High-Risk (parabens/fragrance) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (uses oxybenzone/octinoxate) |
FAE Beauty | Clean (no known EDCs) | N/A | High-Risk (contains chemical UV filters: oxybenzone, octinoxate) | Clean (no known EDCs) | N/A (no standalone sunscreen) |
Sugar Cosmetics | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (setting mist had DMDM hydantoin – a formaldehyde donor) | Lower-Risk (likely no parabens, but contains fragrance) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (octinoxate in SPF products) |
Plum | Clean (no parabens or phthalates) | N/A | Lower-Risk (no parabens; may contain natural fragrance) | Lower-Risk (no parabens; mild preservatives) | High-Risk (uses oxybenzone/octinoxate in sunscreen) |
WOW Skin Science | Clean (no parabens; mild preservatives) | N/A | Lower-Risk (no parabens; uses natural oils/fragrance) | Lower-Risk (no parabens; mild preservatives) | High-Risk (uses oxybenzone/octinoxate in sunscreen) |
Pilgrim | Clean (no parabens or phthalates; uses phenoxyethanol) | N/A | Clean (no known EDCs; no petrolatum or chemical SPF) | Clean (no known EDCs) | N/A (no sunscreen product) |
Kay Beauty | Lower-Risk (no parabens; might contain PEGs) | N/A | Lower-Risk (no parabens; uses safe ingredients) | Lower-Risk (no parabens; mild preservatives) | N/A (no sunscreen product) |
Colorbar | High-Risk (parabens, mineral oils) | High-Risk (likely contains parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens/BHT) | High-Risk (oxybenzone/octinoxate) |
MyGlamm | High-Risk (parabens likely) | High-Risk (contains formaldehyde releaser in fixer spray) | High-Risk (fragrance, possibly petrolatum) | High-Risk (contains fragrance or other additives) | High-Risk (oxybenzone/octinoxate) |
Glitz Beauty | Data N/A | Data N/A | Data N/A | Data N/A | Data N/A |
Hince (Korea) | Clean (no harsh chemicals; likely gentle) | N/A | Clean (no parabens or phthalates) | Clean (no known EDCs) | High-Risk (sunscreen products use chemical UV filters) |
Rare Beauty | Clean (no parabens/phthalates) | Lower-Risk (contains antioxidant preservative BHT) | Clean (reformulated without petrolatum; no parabens/phthalates) | Clean (no parabens or fragrance; dermatologist tested) | N/A (no standalone sunscreen in line) |
Brand | Market | Makeup Remover | Makeup Fixer | Lip Balm | Moisturizer | Sunscreen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinique | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk (no parabens/phthalates; might use safe preservative) | Lower-Risk (generally free of parabens; no fragrance) | Lower-Risk (formulas are fragrance-free and paraben-free) | Lower-Risk (no parabens/phthalates/fragrance; may use BHT in some creams) | High-Risk (some sunscreens contain oxybenzone/octinoxate) |
M·A·C | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk (no parabens/phthalates in new formulas; contains phenoxyethanol) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; may contain fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; contains fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; BHT used as antioxidant) | High-Risk (SPF foundations use octinoxate) |
Bobbi Brown | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk (no parabens; contains fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (no parabens; some formulas have fragrance) | High-Risk (SPF products with chemical filters) |
Estée Lauder | India + Int’l | Lower-Risk (new formulas without parabens/phthalates) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; may contain fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | High-Risk (older sunscreens may contain chemical filters) |
Chambor | India (primarily) | High-Risk (parabens, phthalates) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (oxybenzone, octinoxate) |
Maybelline | India + Int’l | High-Risk (parabens, formaldehyde-releasers) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (octinoxate present) |
Lakmé | India Only | High-Risk (parabens, formaldehyde donor) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (parabens) | High-Risk (oxybenzone, octinoxate) |
YSL Beauty | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (new formulas no parabens since 2016; contains fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben-free; has fragrance) | High-Risk (SPF products may use chemical filters) |
NARS | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (new products sans parabens/phthalates; older ones may have them) | Lower-Risk (recent glosses/lip oils are “clean”; older may contain parabens) | Lower-Risk (new blushes are talc/paraben/phthalate-free) | Lower-Risk (new formulas free of parabens/phthalates; minimal fragrance) | High-Risk (older SPF products with chemical filters; new ones tend to be mineral/clean) |
Tarte | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (no parabens, phthalates, triclosan; BHT in a few products) | Lower-Risk (similarly “clean” formulated) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (no major EDCs) | Lower-Risk (mostly mineral sunscreens; no oxybenzone) |
Gucci Beauty | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (new line is paraben & phthalate free; contains fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | High-Risk (SPF foundation likely uses chemical filters) |
Dior | Int’l Only | Lower-Risk (responsible formulation sans parabens/phthalates; contains fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | Lower-Risk (paraben/phthalate-free; has fragrance) | High-Risk (older sunscreens had oxybenzone; new-gen foundations exclude it) |
Glossier | Int’l Only | Clean (no parabens or phthalates in any product) | Clean (no parabens or phthalates) | Clean (reformulated without petrolatum; no parabens/phthalates) | Clean (no parabens or phthalates; minimal fragrance) | N/A (no sunscreen product) |
Sources: Ingredient information was compiled from official brand disclosures, “free-from” claims, and safety databases. For example, Zoobop’s safety audit reports show many Indian brands like Nykaa, Sugar, Colorbar, MyGlamm, Lakmé, Chambor still use parabens, phthalates (often via undisclosed fragrance), BHT/BHA, oxybenzone, octinoxate, etc. Newer Indian brands (Plum, WOW, Pilgrim, Kay) avoid parabens/phthalates but may include chemical UV filters or fragrance. Global “clean beauty” brands like Rare Beauty and Tarte explicitly formulate without parabens, phthalates, triclosan, oxybenzone, etc, though some use BHT as an antioxidant. Legacy international brands (MAC, Clinique, Bobbi Brown, Estée Lauder, Dior, YSL, NARS, Gucci) have recently moved toward safer formulas (no parabens or phthalates) in new launches, but certain products still contain fragrance or chemical sunscreens. Glossier is noted to be entirely paraben- and phthalate-free. This comparative table highlights that “clean” options (free from known EDCs) are expanding across brands, but many mainstream products remain High-Risk due to the presence of proven or potential endocrine disruptors in their ingredients. Each consumer should check specific product ingredient lists to make the most informed choice.
Get Athos Pro